My natural inclination is to buy every single book that catches my eye. However when my funds or bookshelf footage is running low I try to be more discriminating in what I buy. When I'm in the bookstore I've developed a technique for evaluating books whose reputation I don't know.
In order:
- Check the index (if it has one), skim for terms/people I'm familiar with interested in and jump to the page. Read a few paragraphs on that topic.
- Check the ToC(if it has one), see if the chapter names stoke the same excitement that the title did when it got me to pick it up.
- Pick a chapter and read a page or two.
I make my judgment off of that. What exactly I'm looking for in the words depends on the sort of book (and has changed over the years), but here are a few things that jump out to me these days.
- In fiction: Descriptions of people's manners that are so vivid and on-point that they highlight the author's understanding of how people are.
- In non-fiction concise, explicit, concrete points being made. (Recently reading Sense of Beauty by Santayana on the strength of this.)
- Lots more semi-tangibles.
What about you? How do you evaluate a book?
by pchrisl
1 Comment
Pick a page and then read a paragraph at random. If it doesn’t contain something surprising or unusual, put it back on the shelf