September 2024
    M T W T F S S
     1
    2345678
    9101112131415
    16171819202122
    23242526272829
    30  

    I would like to share the books I have read this year with a brief review of each, and would love to hear responses and especially opposing opinions. The list is from most recently finished to oldest. This is very general so as to not give away any spoilers.

    1: Never Let Me Go, by Kazuo Ishiguro

    In my opinion this is overrated, but consistently makes it to the top of most "Best Books of…" lists. I thought all the dialogue and drama between the children seemed contrived and unnatural. There was nothing special about the prose or language, and I was rather bored for most of the book. I did like the ending as it gave more context and I can see how it would make some people very emotional.

    2: A Movable Feast, by Earnest Hemmingway

    I love Hemmingway, but when I read this I did not realize that this was non-fiction, but I actually loved it. Hemmingway talks about his interactions in 1920's Paris with other artists and writers, at a time in his life where he had not yet enjoyed much commercial success.

    3: Jane Eyre, by Charlotte Bronte

    My favorite book of this year. I absolutely love the language, prose, and the storyline. It's about a girl that grows up in a kind of rough childhood as an orphan and a potential gentleman love interest that she meets, who could be described as unattractive. I read this on Kindle. I have a great vocabulary, but still had to consult the dictionary frequently (and I love this).

    4: Atonement, by Ian McEwan

    This may be my second favorite book this year. The events of the book span about 60 years. It is about a young, imaginative girl that misinterprets another couple's lovemaking and there are accusations and the effects of this on the family dynamic throughout many years later, including the war. The ending was very well done. I love it when an author can do this. I love when an author can tie up every loose end. I feel praise for this book is well deserved.

    5: Treasure Island, by Robert Louis Stevenson

    Most people know the general premise of the story- pirates and treasure. Some parts were entertaining and others didn't hold my interest. Overall, I am glad that I read it.

    6: Murder on the Leviathin, by Boris Akunin

    The book is written in Russian and translated into English and is part of a series. I did not care for Christie's And Then There Were None, but I thoroughly enjoyed this book. It is a murder mystery that in my opinion is much better done than the aformentioned book.

    7: Baudolino, by Unberto Eco

    I have not read In the Name of the Rose. Baudolino is originally in Italian. Its about a peasant boy adopted by a Roman Emperor and is quite an epic story. Some of the politics and the sacking of cities and stuff had a little trouble drudging through. The second half of the book takes on a little more fantasy elements, which I enjoyed more. It's a longer book, around 600 pages, and it took me two months but I was also reading others at the same time. When I finally finished I was glad I read it. I don't know that I'm in a rush to read his other novel that I mentioned. I suppose you could call this historical fiction, but I don't know enough about this time in history to tell which parts are based on real events.

    8: The Fellowship of the Ring, by J R R Tolkien

    I have read the series about 4 times in my life and started again. I plan to read The Two Towers later this year. Always fun and an easy read (though I have heard some people say they have trouble with the language). In my opinion this series is the marker by which all other books in this genre are measured. Tolkien was a genius in the same way that others describe Terry Pratchett, though I have not actually read any of his books yet.

    9: Salem's Lot, by Stephen King

    This was my first King book. I have just started 11/22/63 which was written around 30-35 years later, and I though that the more recent one was more polished. It's about a sleepy Maine town with a vampire problem. I have not yet formed an opinion on King and do not want to do so prematurely. I know he is well loved. This is a long book over 600 pages and found it a very easy read and entertaining, though not the type of book I normally read.

    10: Grave Descend, by Michael Crichton

    This was an Ebook which was available on Hoopla. I have always found Crichton fun. I don't have much to say about this. It was short, around 120 pages if I recall. I would describe it as unmemorable.

    11: The Martian, by Andy Weir

    This is an author who is well loved by many and is about an astronaut that is accidentally left behind on Mars, hence "The Martian." Many of the situations were pretty unplausible but somewhat based in science. The book lacks character development, and has a very plain prose, and I was falling asleep by then end. I would say I prefer the movie MUCH more. Sometimes I wonder how a book attains as much success as it does.

    12: Notes From the Underground, by Fyodor Dostoevsky

    He may be my favorite author. This is a shorter read and requires less commitment than his much longer novels. It is about a lowly ranking public servant Petersburg, Russia, I believe in the late 19th century. The man lives in poor conditions and is looked down upon by his peers. I don't love this nearly as much as his more acclaimed works, but definitely worth the few hours it takes to read.

    13: Jurassic Park, by Michael Crichton

    This is probably the novel I have read the most times in my life, this and LOTR. The Spielberg flick with the same title is based on this. The book is much darker than the film and the characters are different. Spielberg took some liberties for the sake of making it more cinematic. I love everything Crichton and liked the film equally. The book is much more technical and science based than the movie, and in my opinion is MUCH better executed than The Martian.

    14: Tender is the Night

    I read The Great Gatsby in high school and do not remember much. This novel is somewhat based on Fitzgerald's life. The novel is set in the 1920's and is about a psychiatrist who marries one of his patients and the story centers around their private life as well as their interactions in their circle of friends. The protagonist's alcoholism complicates his life as well as his mentally ill wife. I don't remember Gatsby, but some say that this one is his masterpiece. I listened to part of this as an audiobook (and read at the same time) and though I don't remember the narrator's name, her ability to portray the different accents and speak French added much more to my experience. After reading this I listened to several biographies of his life on YouTube and added more context. Highly recommended.

    15: If on a Winter's Night a Traveler, by Italo Calvino

    The premise of this book is interesting, and about the reader's experience reading a book and searching for it when it is lost. It is a little difficult to follow with the shifting narrative/perspective. I don't remember it well (maybe because I did not care for it much), but if you enjoy books that are "different," then you may have fun with this one.

    So there you have it. I am not as prolific of a reader as some other people, but I also tend to favor longer non-fiction novels, and some days only read 10-20 pages. I think it is hard for someone to argue that they have no time for reading. As I said I welcome discussion.

    EDIT: I also DNF'd a book- Deathless, by Catherynne Valente. I only got about 15 or 20% into the book. It is about a young girl who watches her older sisters being married off. The suiters are chicks that fall from trees and morph into young, handsome men and knock on her door. There is of course more which I have forgotten. It adopts fairy tale elements and they may be based off of existing stories. I have not sold or donated the book yet, so perhaps at some time I will give it another go.

    I rarely DNF a book. I always do a little research first and read excerpts first. In this case I only read a single sentence comparing it to some other author that I like. This is why I prefer to not go into a book blind. Then, when I read 30 or 40% of a book and decide I don't like it, I feel committed to reading it because of all of the time I spent.

    by jcoffin1981

    27 Comments

    1. practiceprompts on

      i think it’s time for me to finally read Jurassic Park. it’s been long enough since i’ve seen the movie that all i remember are the memes, so a great time to start fresh

      is the line “hold onto your butts” in the book or was that just SLJ doing his thing?

    2. I really like your list – it’s nice to see people reading some modern novels which are a bit older (like Atonement). I feel like books like that don’t come up in here as frequently but maybe that’s just me.

      I read “if on a winters…” earlier this year and really struggled with it. I felt like I was waiting to understand the point of WHY it was so complex, but that never really came, and I found it self indulgent.

      I absolutely love “Jurassic park” though. A great read.

    3. BuckleUpBuckaroooo on

      Wow I also read Tender is the Night and Salem’s Lot this year. I also highly enjoyed TITN, loved how the perspective changes.
      I will say that out of the 10ish King books I’ve read, 11/22/63 is my favorite and Salem’s Lot is probably in the bottom half.

    4. I couldn’t put The Martian down when I read it in 2016 on vacation in Hawai’i! I also loved the movie, but read the book first.

    5. Klutzy_Masterpiece60 on

      The dialogue and drama in Never Let Me Go was purposely meant to feel weird and unnatural. The constant sense of unease the book conveyed was kinda the point of it. I definitely felt uncomfortable throughout and can’t say I “enjoyed” reading it, but I can appreciate it from an artistic perspective. It’s like how movies like Foxcatcher, Taxi Driver, or the Joker aren’t really enjoyable experiences, but rather purposefully unsettling.

    6. Junior-Air-6807 on

      >Sometimes I wonder how a book attains as much success as it does.

      I don’t even know how that book got published

    7. Impossible_Fig_ on

      I felt exactly the same about Never Let Me Go – I think I was expecting a lot more going into it and had to push myself to finish it. The premise of it sounded right up my street, but it just didn’t wow me like I expected.

    8. Ishiguro is one of my favorite authors and I don’t like Never Let Me Go either—I would highly recommend The Remains of the Day, which imo is the superior book by every metric. I totally agree with you on Jane Eyre, Treasure Island, and (though it’s been years since I read it) The Martian. I also read my first Stephen King novel this year (Pet Sematary) and had a very similar experience. Where we overlap, my only divergence is with Jurassic Park; it’s been years since I read it but I don’t love it nearly as much as you.

    9. Notes from the underground was tough for me to read. I found myself mostly uninterested and the protagonist(if you even call him that) is unbearable in such a way that you can draw parallels to your own shit behavior but not in a way that I found it to be an engaging read.

      I’m glad it was short, if it were longer I probably would have set it down. It was a nice example of how not to live.

    10. Minute_Pianist8133 on

      If you enjoyed Jane Eyre so much, have you tried any of Jane Austen’s novels in the past? Highly recommend. They are more light hearted than anything by the Brontë sisters, but have that same lyrical prose that early modern fiction is known for.

    11. UniqueCelery8986 on

      I can’t wait to read Jane Eyre! I just finished Wuthering Heights by her sister and I loved it. I also plan on reading Salem’s Lot soon (I’ve only read The Shining by King so far)

    12. carbonmonoxide5 on

      I liked Never Let Me Go but Ishiguro has much stronger books. I highly recommend The Remains of the Day or Klara and the Sun if you go for another Ishiguro book. They’re way stronger.

      Interesting take on King. I love Salem’s Lot. Most people seem to agree that his earlier works of stronger by virtue of having an editor. At some point in his career King could basically write any length of novel he wanted without strong editing passes making a lot of his later books weaker. But maybe he’s come out the other side now with more polished works. I don’t know. If you want an epic read The Stand. If you want something spooky read Pet Semetary.

    13. I don’t know that I fully agree with the Never Let Me Go take but I also feel it’s overrated. I am a huge Ishiguro fan though. Remains of the Day and The Buried Giant are top tier.

      Also, Atonement is incredible

    14. I love your list even though I disagree about The Martian. Great mini-reviews, and books to add to my list.

    15. If you love Crichton, I would recommend Blake Crouch. Particularly *Dark Matter* and *Recursion*. He is not as good as Crichton, imo, but does a great job of filling the pseudoscience-fiction hole left behind by Crichton’s death.

    16. -greek_user_06- on

      Oh, so many great books! I LOVE LOTR books and movies. I own the books in the Greek translation and I have read the trilogy four times. I’m planning to buy and read the trilogy in English. The experience will be truly magical.

      Jane Eyre has been on my tbr for a long time. I want to read it sooo badly!

    17. AntAccurate8906 on

      I also thought Never Let Me Go was a bit overrated. I think the dialogues being awkward and the characters not being so likeable is the consequence of their bringing up, so I didn’t dislike that; but I have only read excellent things about it and everyone said they bawled their eyes etc. but it was just a good read for me, I didn’t think about it the next day after I finished

    18. BlancheDeveraux44 on

      There is a new adaptation of Salem’s Lot airing soon on Max now that you’ve read the book 🙂

    19. I read Atonement this year as well! Such a beautiful and moving book. I remember getting chills when I started the last act after I realized what was happening – wonderful read

    20. I also felt the Martian fell a little flat. I didn’t have an issue with the character development or the prose, I liked the way it was written. I just think I didn’t really like all of the explanations it had to give, but that may just be my issue with sci-fi as a genre, I’m much more interested in characters, emotion, and plot.

      I loved Jurassic Park, i have other books by Crichton but haven’t read them yet partly because I don’t think they’ll be as good as Jurassic park. (Although I did read Eruption at the recommendation of my dad, but it was bad and published posthumously so I don’t count it)

    21. Massive_Bluebird1640 on

      I personally have never been a fan of King but I haven’t read Salems Lot. It might be worth a read. Thanks for the suggestions on the other books more to add to my TBR pile.

    Leave A Reply