November 2024
    M T W T F S S
     123
    45678910
    11121314151617
    18192021222324
    252627282930  

    It was recommended to me years ago. I finally picked up a copy of this award-winning classic and found myself underwhelmed.

    • The plot itself was fine but the detailing of everything was like a test of my ability to visualize things, and the description (especially when laying out the setting) was written in such a dry, tedious way.
    • The scheme itself was just so unrealistic. It was so over the top and relied on so many mechanical and theatrical factors that I just couldn't suspend my sense of disbelief.
    • I'm not sure I understood the narrator. They're omniscient, but also actively telling you that they're only recounting reports made by characters and/or taking liberties with events/conversations to which they weren't privy?

    I really wanted to like the book. I even questioned if it was just that prose or tone or impact were getting lost in translation, but I've not had this problem with translations of other Japanese authors.

    I read that he has another 76 books about this character, so:

    Are they all like this? Because if so, I don't think I'd be inclined to read more of his work.

    by itsNotYourKey

    Leave A Reply