September 2024
    M T W T F S S
     1
    2345678
    9101112131415
    16171819202122
    23242526272829
    30  

    46 Comments

    1. I still don’t understand the love for The Underground Railroad, cool concept but found it boring.

    2. The #1 book has been my favorite book of all time since I read it last year. Nothing else has ever been “in my head” the way this book was. It felt like reading my own auto-biography.

      This feels like a personal victory to me lol

    3. Puzzled-Silver6935 on

      No Murakami or Erdrich is very surprising. Would’ve expected at least one

    4. The absence of any volume of Karl Ove Knausgaard’s *My Struggle* on the entire list is a travesty.

    5. The most glaring omissions on this list are certainly from international authors in translation. Others have mentioned the lack of Knausgaard and Murakami (although I’m less surprised by Murakami since he seems to be held as a bit lowbrow by the establishment). But I was most surprised at Olga Tokarczuk’s not being present. She won the Nobel so recently, and while I understand *Books of Jacob*, despite being her opus and tour de force, is probably daunting and still unread, I know a lot of people who have read and greatly admired *Flights* and *Drive Your Plow over the Bones of the Dead*, even though I myself have not read them.

      I am curious though what everyone would put on their list. Here’s mine:

      * *2666* by Roberto Bolaño
      * *Books of Jacob* by Olga Tokarczuk
      * *Tainaron: Mail from Another City* by Leena Krohn (Technically written in the ’80s, but allowable by NYT rules, since the English translation was not until the 2000s.)
      * *Wolf Hall* by Hilary Mantel
      * *Never Let Me Go* by Kazuo Ishiguro
      * *White Teeth* by Zadie Smith
      * *Tyll* by Daniel Kehlmann
      * *Kafka on the Shore* by Haruki Murakami (I seriously debated this one. I don’t think it’s one of the best novels or even one of my favorites. But when I first read it about 10 years ago, I read it in two sittings, and it has remained vibrantly in my brain since. And I think that counts for something when the other books I considered for its spot (*Runaway*, *Middlesex*, *Lincoln in the Bardo*) have felt more transitory.)
      * *The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier and Clay* by Michael Chabon
      * *Fun Home* by Alison Bechdel

    6. jimmyslaysdragons on

      Thanks for sharing! I consider myself a pretty avid reader, so I was surprised to have not even heard of 30-40% of these. But I mostly read nonfiction and sci-fi, and the list seemed to lean very heavily toward a specific subset of American literary fiction.

      The little check boxes were a nice feature. I have read 9 of these books, and I want to read another 25 of them.

    7. Dancing_Clean on

      I was totally expecting Susanna Clarke’s Piranesi to make this list.

      And I loved Stay True by Hua Hsu so I’m happy to see it get representation.

      A Visit from the Goon Squad is a book that annoyed me to bits but I know it’s widely loved and acclaimed.

      Say Nothing has been on my list for a while, especially after reading Empire of Pain.

    8. MY TALLY

      I’ve read 18 books on the list …

      My Brilliant Friend ● The Underground Railroad ● Never Let Me Go ● The Year of Magical Thinking ● Outline ● Evicted ● Americanah ● White Teeth ● Citizen ● Between the World and Me ● A Mercy ● Persepolis ● The Vegetarian ● Middlesex ● Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow ● The Story of the Lost Child ● The Days of Abandonment ● On Beauty

      … and I want to read 7.

      The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao ● Pachinko ● The Years ● The Argonauts ● The Goldfinch ● Detransition, Baby ● The Sympathizer

    9. hellocloudshellosky on

      Did James McBride appear anywhere?
      I wish they had eliminated the possibility of having an author represented by more than one title, so that we’d have had 100 Authors. Which I know goes against the premise, but I’m so frustrated with how weak this list is that wot the hell.

    10. Was (pleasantly) surprised to see Hurricane Season on there, what an insane read. Though i’m curious how well the book works in English.

      Two spots for Bolaño is well deserved, but Against the Day got snubbed.

    11. frenchfriedpizza on

      1 My Brilliant Friend Elena Ferrante; translated by Ann Goldstein 2012

      2 The Warmth of Other Suns Isabel Wilkerson 2010

      3 Wolf Hall Hilary Mantel 2009

      4 The Known World Edward P. Jones 2003

      5 The Corrections Jonathan Franzen 2001

      6 2666 Roberto Bolaño; translated by Natasha Wimmer 2008

      7 The Underground Railroad Colson Whitehead 2016

      8 Austerlitz W.G. Sebald; translated by Anthea Bell 2001

      9 Never Let Me Go Kazuo Ishiguro 2005

      10 Gilead Marilynne Robinson 2004

      11 The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao

      12 The Year of Magical Thinking Joan Didion 2005

      13 The Road Cormac McCarthy 2006

      14 Outline Rachel Cusk 2015

      15 Pachinko Min Jin Lee 2017

      16 The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay

      17 The Sellout Paul Beatty 2015

      18 Lincoln in the Bardo George Saunders 2017

      19 Say Nothing Patrick Radden Keefe 2019

      20 Erasure Percival Everett 2001

      21 Evicted Matthew Desmond 2016

      22 Behind the Beautiful Forevers Katherine Boo 2012

      23 Hateship, Friendship, Courtship, Loveship, Marriage Alice Munro 2001

      24 The Overstory Richard Powers 2018

      25 Random Family Adrian Nicole LeBlanc 2003

    12. I’ve tried to read My Brilliant Friend literally 4 times and can’t get into it. It bums me out. On paper it’s exactly the type of book I would like. Anyone else?

    13. wafflesandlicorice on

      Wow, I have read exactly three of these. But I do have another 20 or so sitting in my TBR piles in my house, and probably another dozen on my TBR list.

    14. I have a sneaking suspicion that this will be one of the last times we see a Munro book ranked this highly on a ‘best of’ list.

    15. Zero books on the list from Suzanna Clarke, Neil Gaiman, Jeff Vandermeer, and China Mieville. It really indicates that the voters are just ignoring literary fantasy/sci-fi because it’s “genre fiction” even though authors such as these are writing just as creative, unique, and meaningful works as any author that gets classified as “literary fiction”.

    16. _unrealcity_ on

      I’ve read 15 (a few more I DNF’d). My Brilliant Friend is well, brilliant, and I’ve no issues seeing it in the top spot.

      The Sympathizer should be wayyyy higher on the list…out of the 15 that I’ve read it’d probably be #1 for me personally.

      So glad to see Han Kang here, one of my favorite authors. But no Japanese fiction??? Really? I’d for one add Meiko Kawakami’s Breasts and Eggs.

      Tomorrow, Tomorrow, and Tomorrow will probably be a polarizing pick…seemed like it was mostly popular among booktokers…but I personally really enjoyed it too and it was a nice surprise to see it here.

      Didn’t like Bel Canto, surprised to see it here as Ann Patchett’s only entry. A Visit From the Good Squad and Station Eleven were pretty forgettable imo, but they were quite popular so I guess not super surprising picks.

    17. I’d like to see a similar list from a hundred years ago and compare it to the works that are well-known today.

    18. -UnicornFart on

      I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR SOMEONE TO POST THIS WITHOUT A STUPID FUCKING PAYWALL

      THANK YOU

    19. I’ve read six of them:

      Never Let Me Go

      The Road

      Lincoln in the Bardo

      Atonement

      Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow

      Station Eleven

      Most of these books I think are great and belong here, but I found Station Eleven boring. Great premise but the book doesn’t live up to it.

    20. I’m a fan of Denis Johnson’s works. How is Train Dreams and Tree of Smoke?

    21. chattahattan on

      My Brilliant Friend (or really, the Neapolitan novels as a whole, since I think of them more as one very long story) at #1 was a pleasant surprise and, in my view, definitely earned. An absolute epic of womanhood. There is absolutely no writer I’ve ever read who can capture the nuances of a person’s internal life quite like Ferrante.

    22. No Good lord bird, no cloud cuckoo land, 2 of my most recent favorites. The sellout on here is pretty awesomr

    23. Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow continues to be one of the most overrated books of the 21st century. You spend decades following characters through a tedious plot only to realize at the end that they’re all insufferable.

    24. I’ve read around Twenty and agree that most of these are five stars for me. But a Visit From the Goon Squad is a weird choice. It was fun and interesting but I don’t remember anything remarkable about it really. Just a wacky romp. Also “The Years” was amazing but I felt like it was very a very niche trip down memory lane for women of a certain age. I loved it because it was aimed right at me, but wonder if it has a broad appeal.

    25. One book that is missing that I haven’t seen others mention is Betty by Tiffany McDaniel. One of the most powerful books I’ve ever read

    26. Never Let Me Go at number nine let’s fucking gooooo

      I would have substituted The Underground Railroad with The Nickel Boys, I thought that was much better.

      Also Lost Children Archive would definitely be on here, tha fact that it isn’t is a crime.

    27. Hot take – The Corrections isn’t even the best Franzen book, let alone #5 in the century

    28. anthropomorphist on

      I’ve only heard of 3 of these. clearly i am not of the 21st century lol

    29. WOW, a book I love didn’t make the list and I book I didn’t love is ranked high??

    30. Capable_Average_8425 on

      I have to know what book the smallest amount of people selected for “Have Read” on this list is. I’d bet on Robert Caro.

    31. Surprised at no Sally Rooney. Normal People was a really impactful book for me, esp reading it when I was in college myself.

    32. notcool_neverwas on

      I adore The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier and Clay. Glad to see it included.

      I’m currently reading Lincoln in the Bardo, after discovering George Saunders’ short-story collections. So far, so good!

      The Overstory is a book I keep picking up and, for some reason, keep putting down. I don’t know what it is, I just cannot get into this story enough to just finish the damn thing.

      I remember Goon Squad winning the Pulitzer and being so shocked, because I thought that book was awful lol

    33. littlestbookstore on

      I’ve read 33 and the only surprise is that I agree with almost nothing 

      My hot-takes (bring on the downvotes):   

      Tons of snubs for spec-fic/sci-fi.  No Ted Chiang or Ken Liu or Van der Meer or Kelly Link? 

       Why isn’t Interior Chinatown by Charles Yu on here?  

       “Trust Exercise” by Susan Choi   

       No Chang Rae Lee?   

       All the Light We Cannot See??  

       George Saunders 3x, really?? He’s great, but seriously  

       Alice Munro?? I say this as someone who was ever really able to get into her work in the first place  

      I never understood the appeal of Denis Johnson   

       Lauren Groff should be on here   

       Hernan Diaz’s “In the Distance” is far superior to “Trust”  

       “Austerlitz” is not Sebald’s best either   

       ~~“Blind Assassin” should be on here~~ Ok, I was under the impression that 2000 counted, but ok, crossing it off.    

       Where is Olga Tokarczuk??  

       “The Idiot” by Elif Batuman should be on here 

         Ffs, the NYT is turning into the Academy. Clique-y, political, insiders only.  … sorry, not sorry, I have strong feelings 

    34. GingerMan027 on

      I would have put ‘Cloud Atlas’ higher. I think the movie adaptation wasn’t at all equal to the book and that hurt it.

      ‘The Road’ was a lesser book by McCarthy, to me.

      There’s several there I’ll be checking out. Literally from the library.

    35. 60minutesmoreorless on

      My list of Overlooked Titles:

      The Map and the Territory – Houellebecq,
      The Pale King – Wallace,
      Annihilation – Vandermeer,
      Gone Girl – Flynn,
      A Naked Singularity – de la Pava,
      My Struggle – Knausgaard,
      A Time for Everything – Knausgaard,
      The Infatuations – Marias,
      There There – Orange,
      House of Leaves – Danielewski,
      Orfeo – Richard Powers

    36. squeakyrhino on

      *Was very happy to see When We Cease to Understand the World on here. That book blew my mind.

      *Surprised that Say Nothing made the list but not Empire of Pain. Both are brilliant! I actually think the latter is better but it might be recency bias.

      *I find it interesting how many authors had No Country for Old Men on their lists, but The Road is the only representation McCarthy gets on here.

    37. BooksWritten4Girls on

      Have read Days of Abandonment, A Manual for Cleaning Women, The Vegetarian, Citizen, White Teeth (dnf), Americanah, Say Nothing, Pachinko (dnf), The Road, Never Let Me Go, Underground Railroad, 2666 (currently reading and The Savage Detectives by Bolaño is my next read)

      Pleasantly surprised A Little Life wasn’t on the listed.
      Neutrally surprised by no Ottessa Moshfegh (have Death In Her Hands and Lapvona tanked her reputation?)
      Less pleasantly surprised by Pachinko’s placement and the lack of: Sayaka Murata, Olga Tokarczuk, Max Porter, David Diop, Hiroko Oyamada, Elisa Shua Dusapin, Natsuo Kirino, Anne Carson, and/or Ocean Vuong.

      Would be shocked if they did this a year from now and Chain Gang All Stars wasn’t on it.

    38. thenewyorktimes on

      hi! thank you for sharing our list! we do also have more lists from this week, including:

      * [the 10 best books of the century according to other writers and book lovers and ](https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/books/authors-top-books-21st-century.html?unlocked_article_code=1.6k0.NjCP.DIiABaqV9bjO&smid=re-nytimes)
      * [a list of books that didn’t make our “Best Books of the 21st Century” list](https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/11/books/review/favorite-books-stephen-king-megan-abbott.html?unlocked_article_code=1.6k0.b_5N.bQrLNyRxcSae&smid=re-nytimes) but these authors still made a case for them

      and all of these can be read without an NYT subscription!

      edit: spacing

    Leave A Reply